In the cutthroat world of music, uncleared samples and covers can be a double-edged sword. While they might propel your track to viral status, they can also land you in hot water with copyright holders. The music industry has little patience for those who profit from others' hard work without proper clearance. It's a delicate balance between creative expression and legal obligations. If you're looking to make your mark in the industry by borrowing from others, remember: clearance isn't just a formality—it's your ticket to staying in the game long-term. Let's dive into the complex world of covers, remixes, and samples, and learn how to navigate this treacherous terrain.
What is a cover?
Covers are essentially re-recordings of original compositions. They are best created when performed word-for-word with arrangements close to the original. However, many artists choose to create covers that deviate from the original by changing lyrics, style, language, or other elements—moving them further from the original composition to give it their own unique flair. It’s important to note that artists creating new lyrics over previously released instrumentals are not covers and they should obtain clearance from the publishers as well as the record label.
What is a Remix?
Remixes are new creations based on original compositions, designed to appeal to a different audience than initially intended. These can be produced by the original record labels or by independent producers and DJs seeking to establish their brand and reputation. They can also be recorded by artists seeking validation to build their brand as well. It's important to distinguish remixes from sampling. Remixes typically use a substantial portion—if not all—of the original sound recording and composition to create a new track. In contrast, samples utilize a smaller portion of the sound recording and composition.
What is a sample?
Samples are pieces of sound recordings and compositions combined, chopped up, and used in a new sound recording and composition. Most samplers sample to give songs added character or style while others use sampling for the purposes of siphoning the popularity from previous songs to make theirs popular much more easily. In addition to the techniques, there are many more.
What is a Parody?
Parodies are covers with significant changes to lyrics, style, tempo, and original intended purpose—primarily for comedy or political satire. Many people recognize parodies as meme songs on social media. In some cases, publishers may consider the clearance process for a parody similar to that of a sample due to its uniqueness compared to the original version.
How do you clear a sample?
To sample a song, you need clearance from both the master copyright holders (labels) and the composition copyright holders (publishers). Deborah Mannis-Gardner, speaking at an AIMP panel, stated, "The standard fee for composition shares (2024) in the sample is $2,500 per ownership share. Publishing clearances are never MFN (Most Favored Nations) with master clearances... Like in sync. This is because labels don't get to own new masters, but publishers do get to own rights to the new composition." This means the master clearance side can be extremely expensive! Deborah prefers sending requests rather than offers because "you never know what you're going to get on the other side."
How do you clear a cover?
Covers can be easily cleared if they are not significantly changed from the original arrangement in lyrics, song structure, gender, etc. Sites like Songfile and Easy Song can fulfill your mechanical licensing arrangements without much fuss. However, to get partial copyright ownership of the new composition as well as performance royalties, you must clear the song with the original publisher. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. In many cases, the new cover artist will not get a portion of the new arrangement however if the publisher sees that there were some tasteful original changes they will bend to give you some ownership in the new composition.
How do you clear a Parody?
Parodies are essentially covers with severe significant changes to lyrics, melodies, and arrangements, and style of the original composition. In some cases, publishers will call it a sample if it is really distasteful alerting the label that owns the recording as well to put a cease and desist to your song. It all depends. However, you can expect to negotiate with the publisher to keep a portion of the composition because your arrangement is so different. The downside is it may cost you just as much as the sample on the composition side.
How do you clear a remix?
Remixers typically receive 0% publishing from the music publisher, and the record label often demands ownership of the master in exchange for a flat fee or royalty percentage. In this case, you're not sampling but rather blending the original master and composition with other components or newly created compositions (beats). Even then, you're still using the original vocals from the sound recording that were part of the original sold, performed arrangement. However, some publishers may be willing to negotiate as your popularity grows, leveraging your branding in the remix.
If you decide to clear your songs
Clearing songs can lead to valuable new relationships for future clearances. It also grants you ownership of compositions, and building your catalog. If you can afford the clearance, your catalog's value can increase significantly, depending on the cover's popularity. Cleared covers and samples allow you to enter the sync world confidently. If your work is exceptional, you may even receive requests from labels to remix or cover their recordings, simply because you've done such a great job with previous clearances.
If you are new and do not clear your songs
For standard covers, you can expect no trouble but forfeit all of the publishing, calling it fair. If you decide to sample, however, you can expect multiple takedown notices, closed distributor accounts, or even worse—being served papers for small claims federal copyright court or "big boy" federal copyright court. These legal troubles will cause you headaches and financial strain.
Tools for Independence
If you're a music creative or executive looking to build your label or publishing company in 60 days or less, with a step-by-step fool proof process, Grab the 60 Day record label course and get it done today! You gain the ability to get real funding, prevent yourself from getting screwed contractually, and keep the middle man out of your pockets. Click the link below to get started right now! If you’re skeptical grab the free guide, "10 Ways to Increase Your Record Labels Profits," a free split sheet comes with the download!
Conclusion
If you were struggling to understand the difference between all of these you now have some knowledge of the difference of all of them.
Comments